| |
Basic InformationLookupsLatest NewsQuestions and AnswersVideosWhat is Lupus and Who Gets It?Could You Have PrediabetesResist Taking Unnecessary AntibioticsTaking Energy Drinks to Heart Weathering MigrainesCrohn's vs Ulcerative Colitis Six Things You Need to Know About EbolaHeadache or Migraine?Preventing Pre-Diabetes Getting Radiation During Breast Cancer SurgeryAntibiotics Aren’t Always The AnswerAdult Onset Asthma Healthy Eating for a DiabeticYounger People Slower to get Diabetes Diagnosis Recognizing Type 1 & Type 2 Diabetes Diabetes: Know Your NumbersCold or Allergy? What You REALLY Need to Know about EbolaSignals You May be Ready for Joint Replacement Slowing the Spread of Superbugs TelehealthE.Coli FactsDiabetes Doesn’t Disappear Infectious Diseases A-Z: MeaslesWhen Do You Need an Antibiotic? Are You Having a Heart Attack? The Journey of Palliative Care: Putting Quality Back Into Life Treating 'Stomach Flu'Diabetes- What You Don't Know Could Hurt YouWhy Second Opinions Are Good for PatientsFollow Your Gut: Microbiomes and AgingVaccines 101: How new vaccines are developedTreating Migraines High Blood Pressure: What You Should KnowReading the Stroke SignsBelly Fat Danger Revealed Diagnosing Celiac DiseaseCoronavirus AnxietyAvoiding Illness When TravelingQ&A on Coronavirus - COVID-19 with WHO's Dr Maria Van KerkhoveCoronavirus - 7 Steps to Prevent the Spread of the VirusCoronavirus: How to Talk to KidsAnswering 20 Questions about COVID-19What’s Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS)?What Is Celiac Disease? SymptomsPrevention and Control of Skin Cancer Tackling ConcussionsUnderstanding Parkinson's diseaseCarpal Tunnel: Who Gets It? Asthma 101 Health and Wellness: Taking a Stand Against Sitting Back Pain: Oh My Aching Back Itching for Answers: Testing Your Allergy IQ Keeping Kidneys Safe - Know How Medicines Affect the Kidneys The Role of Family History in Breast Cancer What is Diabetes Do your part to stop the spread of flu at home Could You Have Prediabetes? Are You at Risk for Kidney Disease? I Have High Cholesterol.. What Should I Do?What Does "Bad" Cholesterol Do?Five Things to Know About MeaslesCeliac Disease 101 - An OverviewAsthma in Children: Working Together to Get it Under ControlTop 3 Tips for a Healthy Heart in the New YearDo your Symptoms Add Up to DiabetesBreakdown on AFib Non-Smokers Getting Lung Cancer Connecting with a Cardiologist A Hot Treatment for AsthmaWho Needs a Flu Vaccine?Keeping Up with Heart FailureTurning the Immune System Against Lung Cancer Dealing with Menopause, Naturally Managing Chronic Disease Pays Off Beyond the Data -- Dengue and Chikungunya in Our Backyard: Preventing Aedes Mosquito-Borne Diseases Peanut Allergies: A Bigger Threat to Kids with Asthma Liver Disease and Anxiety and DepressionImproving Muscle HealthStroke Prevention Diagnosis and Treatment Options Webinar Cancer Clinical Trials: What is a Clinical Trial? Zika VirusYoung People May Need Colonoscopy Working to Eliminate Measles Around the Globe Colorectal cancer: A disease of development Huntington Disease Facts about the Measles (MMR) VaccineLove Your Heart. Everyday Tips to Keep Your Heart Healthy and Strong Does my Child Have Asthma and How Should it be Treated? Superbugs Moving From Hospitals to HomesInfectious Disease Expert Explains MERSHow to Prevent and Detect Skin CancerConcussion Guide for Parents How Your Immune System WorksHow the Digestive System WorksLiving with Lactose Intolerance Avian Flu Faster Healing for Abdominal Surgery The Road to Zero: CDC’s Response to the West African Ebola Epidemic, 2014–2015 Avoiding Heat Exhaustion and Heatstroke Preventing Salmonella and E. coliAdults: Do You Know What Vaccines You Need?Seasonal AllergiesGame Change in Treating Heart Attack Beyond the Data Update -- Climate Change and HealthIncreased Rates of Pregnancy Complications in Women with Celiac DiseaseBehavioral Health Response to EbolaLearning & cognitive difficulties in children: Challenges after a head injury, including concussion Low Testosterone Often Spells Low Bone Density WHO: Prevent hepatitis Allergy OverloadVaccines for Lyme Disease - Past, Present, and FutureBecoming a Living Liver Donor: Evaluation, Risks, and Recovery Breaking Down Hip Fractures Working on Your Back Pain The Heartburn-Asthma Connection Stop the Spread of Antibiotic ResistanceVaccinations and ImmunizationsInfluenza, an Unpredictable Threat Hyper-Hypo Thyroid, What’s the Diff? Reading the Warning Signs of Parkinson’s Older Americans Preventing DiabetesAsthma UpdateGet Vaccinated and Prevent MeaslesFamily History and Heart Disease Breast Feeding and Gluten Introduction: What Research Tells UsRashes: A Brief Overview of the Different Causes Back to School: Sick Kids - Should They Stay or Should They Go? Preventive Cardiology Pumping up Heart Warnings on Pain Relievers Pre-Diabetes a Chance for PreventionCancer - What does it mean that a chemical causes an increase in cancer risk?CDC Urges Sepsis Awareness Managing Celiac Disease Through Diet Learn the ABCs of Ticks with Dr. Bobbi Pritt New Stem Cell Therapy for Crohn’s FistulaTrends and Racial Differences in Celiac DiseaseObesity Can Have Implications Specific to Women Zika Virus 101Coping With Stress: Cognitive-Behavioral Stress Reduction What are the Risk Factors for Kidney Disease? Can Hypnotics Help Celiac Disease Patients Get a Good Night’s Sleep?Aspirin 411: What the New Guidelines Mean Kids With Asthma Who Are Exposed To Secondhand Smoke Have Twice As Many Hospitalizations Ankle Sprains—Pain Free Does Not Mean Normal Sport Concussions in YouthGenetics For Preventive Cardiology ‘Creeping Fat’ May Contribute to IBDWhat’s Triggering Your Allergies? Is There a Link Between Celiac Disease and Heart Disease?Lupus: Your body's immune system attacks your own tissues and organs Psoriasis and beyond: targeting the IL-17 pathway A Review of Treatments Available for Celiac DiseaseHow to handwash? With soap and water Disparities in early childhood obesity: Risk factors and possible solutionsRecognize the Signs and Symptoms of StrokeBone Up on Calcium Lose That Burning Feeling (Heartburn)Thyroid Nodules and Thyroid Cancer: What You Need to KnowZika virus - Questions and answersHeartburn or Something More Serious?Microcephaly and Zika virus infection - Questions and answers Celiac Disease: What Is a Gluten-Free Diet Zika Virus: Four Myths and What You Need to Know Is It a Cold or Allergies? What is Lupus and Who Gets It? 5 tips to keep your gut microbiome healthyLungs & Respiratory System Heart Burn or Heart Attack? How Parents and Caregivers Can Help Kids and Teens Cope with the Increased Stressors with COVID-19How Your Thyroid Impacts Your Weight Don't Underestimate the Dangers of Heat Is it cold, flu or allergies? How Fibromyalgia and Chronic Fatigue Are Related Kids and Common Infections LinksBook Reviews |
| |
by Stephen H. Jenkins Oxford University Press, 2004 Review by David Teira, Ph.D. on Oct 26th 2004
Statistical
literacy is becoming an issue of growing concern for scientists and
philosophers alike, the underlying drive being the social impact it has on a
variety of realms. Sociologists (e.g. Beck) have made us aware of the relevance
of risk assessment in our everyday life, while psychologists (e.g. Gigerenzer)
revealed that our statistical estimations are usually biased, albeit for good
evolutionary reasons. To trust in the statistical expertise of scientists might
then seem a wise choice when their empirical findings are invoked to support
such decisions as, say, the promotion of vitamin C for our health improvement
or a conviction on the basis of DNA identification. The immediate question is
to what extent this public trust is justified.
The
improvement of our understanding of statistical evidence in biology and
medicine is precisely the goal of How Science Works and the
argumentative strategy of the biologist Stephen H. Jenkins could not have been
more effective. Each of the nine chapters of his book provide an introductory
presentation of the evidence available concerning an equal number of
fascinating topics: besides the two mentioned above, Jenkins discusses
environmental and ethological issues (such as the decline of certain amphibian
populations or the cognitive mechanisms that control the storage of food in
certain species), medical subjects (the causes of cancer and aging, the effects
of coffee), or a combination of both (the influence of climate change on the
spread of malaria). Intended as brief reports on the work in progress in all
these areas, each one of them contributes to the making of a single
methodological point: what the statistical analysis proves in these nine cases
is that there are as yet no ultimate answers.
What
Jenkins argues is that this inconclusiveness arises from the very complexity of
biological and medical research, even after being tamed by the most
sophisticated statistical techniques available. There are many sources of
evidence and various possibilities to incorporate them into our theories. On
the one hand, Jenkins presents a number of standard bio-statistical methods
that allow us to design experiments and analyze data with various degrees of
reliability. The art of the biomedical scientist would lie in the achievement
of a certain consilience between all these sources, together with more
traditional ones, such as fieldwork. Jenkins shows that this is not an easy
task, as the evidence might prove unavoidably conflicting. Several
philosophical dilemmas come to complicate even more data analysis. To name just
three, let us think of the typical disjunction (sometimes inclusive, often
exclusive) between case studies and all-encompassing theoretical approaches,
the difficulties of accounting for the simultaneous interaction of various
levels of causality and the pros and cons of purely statistical vs.
mechanism-based modeling.
Though
it might seem impossible to compress such a range of topics into about 200 very
readable pages, Jenkins succeeds in providing a survey that might be of equal
interest both for the curious reader in search for a popular state of the art
discussion of the nine mentioned topics and for the methodologically-minded
scholar looking for an introduction to the beauty and perplexities of
biomedical research. Footnotes are kept to a minimum and several suggested
readings complement each chapter. Jenkins's approach might well be deemed
"ecological": though he clearly favors certain approaches, his main
concern throughout the book is to show us how many of them proliferate now in his
field and what sort of results they yield. Only by taking all this into account
will we be able to qualify our trust in the alleged scientific grounds of many
policies currently under discussion. In other words, the idea of informed
consent should be generalized as to encompass (and legitimate) every public
decision on environmental and medical matters.
Though
Jenkins' case is articulated and convincing, it might be also a bit puzzling.
We may well be aware of the difficulties of attaining conclusive results in the
biomedical sciences, but to whom are we rely on to assess them? Jenkins's
implicit assumption seems to be that there will always be non-partisan
scientific experts to provide a reliable assessment. Yet, it might happen that
controversy among scientists could prevent general audiences from discerning
whom to trust. This is a classical dilemma: quis custodet ipsos custodes?
Be it what it may, Jenkins' proposal will probably be part of the solution to
this problem.
© 2004 David Teira
David Teira, Ph.D., Department of Philosophy,
University of Salamanca (Spain) |