| |
Basic InformationMore InformationTestsLatest NewsQuestions and AnswersVideosHow to Select the Best School Accommodations for Your Child with ADHDHow to Manage ADHD and AnxietyWhat You Need to Know about Students with ADHD and AnxietyADHD and Eating Tourette Syndrome and ADHD Homework, Organization, and Time Management Strategies to Help Kids with ADHDNutrition in Support of ADHD TreatmentBehavioral Therapy: What it is and finding a therapist Project-Based Learning and ADHD Conditions May Mimic ADHDDepartment of Education Guidance Broadens Understanding of 504 Rights for Kids with ADHD Part I Treating ADHD in the African American CommunityHow to Build Self-Motivation in Teens with ADHDGoal Setting and Keeping for the ADHD BrainNeurofeedback Treatment for ADHDADHD in Preschoolers: What to Look For and How to HelpFYI on ADHD Evaluations Teaching Grit, Perseverance and Frustration Tolerance to Students with ADHD Does my Child Have ADHD? How to Start Eating Well When You Have ADHD 5 Solutions for Common ADHD Social StrugglesIs My High School Student Ready for College? (And Is My College Student Ready to Go Back?) Understanding and Applying the Science of Time ManagementADHD Medication and College Students: Prevent Misuse, Abuse, and DiversionImprove Homework Time with Strategies That Work For ADHD Student Voices: What Really Matters to Young Adults With Learning and Attention Issues 5 Ways Nutrition can Impact ADHD Symptoms 3 Tips for Adjusting to a New Diagnosis of ADHDCreating the Best Learning Environment for Students with ADHD ADHD & Executive FunctioningDepartment of Education Guidance Broadens Understanding of 504 Rights for Kids with ADHD Part II Ask The Expert: Neurofeedback Treatment for ADHDADHD and Suicide Risk FactorsThe Choice is in the Details: Medication Options for ADHDUnderstanding and Supporting Young Adults with ADHDHelping Your Young Adult Become IndependentCreating Structure and Routines for Children with ADHDWhen You and Your Child Have ADHD - Communication Skills to Resolve ConflictGuidance for Uncertain Times: Navigating Relationship ChallengesGuidance for Uncertain Times: Mindful Parenting Couples with ADHD: Creating Caring Connection amid the ChaosDisclosure and Workplace Accommodations for Individuals With ADHDA Summer At CampSelf-Advocacy Tips For Teens With ADHDADHD and Curbing Impulsive Spending to Help Your RelationshipADHD: Signs, Symptoms, ResearchADHD & Risk of Adult Drug UseHealth and Life Expectancy in ADHDFocus on ADHDPediatrics: ADHD and Food Allergies ADHD TreatmentADHD: It's a Family AffairDoes Your Child Have ADHD?ADHD in ChildrenLiving with ADHDRise in ADHD Cases in ChildrenWhy is Dating Difficult When You Have ADHDVideo Games, Screens, and ADHD A Potent MixAsk the Expert Helping Children with ADHD LD Conquer Chronic StressAsk the Expert: Mindfulness, Stress, & EmotionAttention Deficit Hyperactivity DisorderAsk the Expert Educator Edition: ADHD & Executive FunctioningAsk the Expert - Academic Evaluations - What Parents Need to Know ADHD and Sibling RelationshipsMedication Treatment for ADHD Using Time Out Treating Childhood ADHD ADHD-friendly Summer Family FUNdamentals Preparing Older Teens for the Road Ahead Tips for Teachers: Tailoring homework to make a difference Your Active Preschooler: Could it be ADHD? Tips for Teachers: Creating a positive dialogue with parents of students with ADHD Helping Parents & Kids Understand the Social & Emotional Aspects of ADHDSocial and Emotional Concerns of Children with ADHD: Strategies to Help Holiday Gifts for Children with ADHDBehavior Management and Combined Treatment for Children with ADHD Setting Realistic School Expectations for Students with ADHD On Their Own: Helping College Students with ADHD Children's Communication Challenges: Is it Attention, Language or Both? Out-of-School: Parenting During the Summer ADHD in the Workplace: Finding Success Emotions and Motivation in ADHDThe Role of Medication in Managing Children's ADHD Symptoms Top Tips for Combating Stigma and Addressing Myths about ADHD Facts and Myths about ADHD What To Do If Your Child Has ADHD? How Common is ADHD? Children, Meds, and Heart Safety: A Tale of ADHD and Public Health ADHD & Your Child’s Transition to CollegeYour Teen with ADHD: Challenges and Strategies for SuccessAsk the Expert - No more homework battles A Frontline to ADHDUnderstanding Girls with ADHD What is ADHD? What To Do When Your Child With ADHD is BulliedStop the Chaos! Tips for Creating a Peaceful Household When Mom has ADHDIs It ADHD?Ask the Expert - What else can I do? Complementary approaches to ADHD treatment All in a row: Getting your kids with ADHD organized Your Student With ADHD Was Admitted to College, Now what? Evidence-based treatment for ADHD in young children Home life when Mom or Dad has ADHD: Succeeding with your family How does technology affect ADHD? Diagnosing ADHD Helping Your Child Successfully Handle Change Recognizing challenging behaviors in young children: Could it be ADHD? Classroom Managment Supports for ADHD Behaviors in Preschool Settings Getting through to your teenager with ADHD What Everyone Should Know about ADHD Make Learning Exciting: Apps for Executive Functioning Teenagers, ADHD, and Substance Abuse Past Procrastination -- Get Your Kids Organized, Focused and MotivatedAsk the Expert: Late, Lost, and Unprepared: How to Help Your Child with Executive Functioning LinksBook Reviews |
| |
Neurodiversity: Is ADHD a True Mental Disorder?Margaret V. Austin, Ph.D., edited by C. E. Zupanick, Psy.D.Controversies Surrounding ADHD
ADHD has become a controversial psychological disorder. Debates center on whether or not ADHD is a mental illness/disability: Perhaps ADHD is merely a variation of a normal condition. There are notable cultural variations and gender differences. Additionally, the accuracy of prevalence rates has been called into question. As we will soon see, these two camps (real disease vs. variation on the norm) have different explanations for the rapid increase in ADHD rates. This controversy is further fueled another debate about the wisdom and ethics of giving children powerful medications; and, the stigma of an ADHD label. This diverse group of concerned people include ADHD professionals, educators, caregivers, child advocates, religious and ethical groups, and others.
Neurodiversity: Is ADHD a true mental disorder?
The central controversy surrounding ADHD is whether or not it is actually a "disorder." Despite well-documented brain differences and significant impairment, some experts do not view these differences as symptoms of a disorder. Instead, they see these differences as normal, but somewhat extreme, variations of human behavior. These experts use the term "neurodiversity" to describe normal, genetic, brain-based variations in behavior.
Some disorders are evidenced by symptoms that represent a complete and total deviation from normal and healthy functioning (e.g., diabetes). Likewise, some conditions are perfectly healthy but uncommon (pregnancy). However, in both cases, these are all or none. You cannot be a little bit pregnant, nor have a touch of diabetes. You either do, or you do not, have these conditions. Think of this like a light switch. It is either on, or it is off.
However, unlike many biologically-based symptoms, behavioral symptoms can be a matter of degree. There are some behaviors that everyone demonstrates to some degree or another (e.g., inattention). Think of this like a dimmer switch with an infinite intensity range from on to off. ADHD is like a dimmer switch. It is characterized by behaviors (inattention, impulsivity, excessive energy, distraction) that everyone demonstrates in varying degrees. Therefore, the question then arises: At what point does something become a disorder?
The neurodiversity argument asserts that since a large portion of the population demonstrate ADHD-like behaviors, albeit to a lesser degree, ADHD is not actually a true disorder. It is simply an extreme example of a normal variant. To complicate matters, as we mentioned before, symptoms like impulsivity and excessive energy are not unique to ADHD. Several disorders have these symptoms. The fact that ADHD symptoms are not exclusive to that disorder seems to bolster the neurodiversity argument that ADHD is not an actual disorder.
Naturally, there are those that oppose the neurodiversity argument that ADHD is not a true disease. These experts readily acknowledge that people naturally vary in terms of energy, attention, and impulsivity. However, these experts emphasize that only some people experience impaired daily functioning as a result. This interference in daily functioning is central to distinguishing disorders from normal variations of behavior. In fact, this problematic interference in social, educational, and/or occupational functioning is a requirement for all psychiatric disorders. In the normal range, behaviors such as occasional inattention or daydreaming tend to be sporadic and are usually present in only one setting. This is in contrast to ADHD where the behaviors are readily observed in multiple settings.
For children with sub-clinical ADHD symptoms, their behaviors may cause them some problems. However, these problematic behaviors are not the dominant behavioral style across different settings. Most children are able to demonstrate some control over their problematic behaviors when sufficiently motivated. In contrast, children with ADHD seem to lack this ability to self-regulate, despite their motivation and desire to do so. Their problematic behaviors are frequent and severe enough to impair their functioning in multiple settings, across time.
Fortunately, this argument over the validity of the ADHD diagnosis has faded in recent years. This is attributable to the increasing number of studies that have found consistent biological differences between people with ADHD, as compared to those without. Repeated findings of biological markers support the idea that ADHD is a diagnosable condition. LINK
Beyond the United States, the international community reached an official agreement about the nature of ADHD. In 2001, over 80 ADHD experts around the globe signed and published the International Consensus Statement on ADHD. The purpose of this document was to challenge widely-held public skepticism and debate surrounding the validity of an ADHD disorder, requiring medication. By 2005, an additional 100 experts in Europe signed their names to the document. This additional support further strengthened and validated the statement that ADHD is indeed a valid mental disorder. At this time, the majority of professionals around the world view ADHD as a true, diagnosable condition.
|